石榴星球

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

微信扫码登录

使用验证码登录

银行新闻

银财银行:刚从一个群里看到,嵌入墙体的AT ...

  • 0
银财银行:刚从一个群里看到,嵌入墙体的ATM自动取款机,在取款的时候,清点钞票的声音,到底是真的,还是录音播放的?没想到得到了大家广泛的。先让我们看看其他童鞋怎么看待的?

20110824111546926.jpg

结束时间: 2013-9-11 16:57

正方观点 (0)

是清点钞票声音

反方观点 (3)

是钞票录音播放

辩手:0 ( 加入 )
     
    辩手:0 ( 加入 )
      银财数字

      写了 290 篇文章,拥有财富 3276,被 2 人关注

      转播转播 分享分享 分享淘帖
      回复

      使用道具

      您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册
      B Color Link Quote Code Smilies
      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:03:50

      时代周刊商业与货币版面是这样说的:(原文地址 http://business.time.com/2011/06 ... pensing-sound-fake/

      In true Pavlovian form, humans are accustomed to getting excited at the sweet sound of an ATM dispensing cash. But is that sound artificially generated? If so, why?

      The website Humans Invent, which is somehow partnered up with Sharp Electronics, posted a roundup of technologies equipped with artificial sounds “designed to help humans.” Ultra-quiet electric vehicles, for instance, are being outfitted to produce “vroom” sounds so that pedestrians and bikes can hear them coming and get out of the way, if need be. Some sports arenas have artificial crowd noises, and while those sounds are designed to help the home team, they mostly serve as reminders (depressing, sorta creepy reminders) that the arena is three-quarters empty.

      The last item in the list is the ATM machine, with its “comforting whirr of the cash point,” as Humans Invent puts it:


          The assumption most people jump to is that the sound is produced by rollers delivering the notes to the collection slot. In fact, the sound is an entirely artificial addition to the process.

          The noise is produced by a speaker and purely included in the transaction to reassure you that your money is on its way. Without the added noise, the ATM would be practically silent with its moving parts on the other side of a brick wall.
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:04:39

      (LIST: 5 Tips to Avoid Getting Scammed)

      Word of these claims quickly spread online, and in a thread at Reddit, several commenters who say they’ve worked on ATMs for years called B.S. One wrote:

      I serviced ATM/ABM machines for over 4 years, there is no artificial sound, the machines really are that loud (and about 10 times louder with the vault door opened) the belts that are spinning to deliver the cash from the cash cassettes to the customer are by no means “practically silent.” And there is no f***in brick wall in the MIDDLE of the damn machines.
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:05:03

      Humans Invent countered by pointing to a Times (of London) story about artificial electric car sounds that quickly and offhandedly also mentions a few other purportedly fake features added to various technologies over the years:

      • An unpleasant odour has been added to natural gas since 300 children died in 1937 after a leak at a Texas school went unnoticed
      • Digital cameras make the sound of a shutter closing to reassure users
      • Cash machines whirr to convince us that our money is on its way
      • Manufacturers use dye to make strawberry ice-cream pink, ketchup red and squash orange
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:05:28

      If the cash-machine sounds are fake, you can understand why designers would make them so. As the great philosopher Jerry Seinfeld once mused:


          They really got us trained to use that cash machine now, don’t they? We’re just like chickens in an experiment waiting for that pellet to come down the chute.

          You see people at the cash machine; they’re just there. Just, dit dit dit dit dit dit dit, they’re waiting for the sound, you know the sound, you’re waiting for the sound. That’s what we’re trained to hear, the ‘here comes the money’ sound, ya know?

          Flip flip flip flip flip flip flip. It’s exciting, don’t you get excited? It’s coming! It’s coming! They’re giving me money!
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:06:30

      ceY8R_QvPXSqT2ffpWLUwvLUWNGcHpn2M62TnUzrWpEdAgAATQIAAFBO.png
      咦,看起来经历了一场腥风血雨的样子。到处都是删除线、“更新”和“编辑附言”。
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:08:05

      加入战团的还有一批reddit网友:

      未命名-1.jpg
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:09:29

      我们把几家意见汇总一下:

      Humaninvent 原始文章:ATM声音是假的。

      Humaninvent收到的大量工程师来信:没有额外扬声器,声音是真的。

      有人的猜想:声音是真的,但也许是转子故意发出了大声音,其实可以不这么大?

      少量人的来信:以前有过假声音,但2000年以后就没了。

      Humaninvent 网友Jordan Harper:Coinstar零钱机有个类似的案例:虽然不是假声音,但有假延迟。其实半秒就数得清,但它故意装作多数了一会儿——显示器上数字上升的速度比真实的速度慢得多。

      (故意延迟的相关讨论:http://www.90percentofeverything ... value-does-it-work/


      Reddit网友kozlojak:我是ATM技师,我做过两家主要ATM厂商的机器,我作证声音是真的。数钱的移动部件很多。

      Reddit网友wickedcold:我和楼上一样。ATM里移动部件超多的,声音巨大,开了门更是如此。NCR家的机器甚至用真空吸钞票。
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:10:01

      YmMJqeI5roCbRsMc7YQ1t6zQMjCqj1Y8F4zB-gs-feBOAQAAJgIAAEpQ.jpg


      这是Diebold取款机的内部结构。工作人员手拿的就是储钱箱,如果有不同面值的钱,就会分储在不同箱子里。可以看到里面有大量的机械零部件。
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      银财数字

      发表于 2013-9-4 17:10:21

      Reddit网友JohnZorZ:humaninvent是胡扯。我修ATM修了4年,没有假声音,机器真的就是那么吵,开门的时候更是吵10倍以上。把钱从钱箱送上去的旋转带子根本不是什么“几乎无声"。而且他妈的ATM机里面哪来的什么鸟砖墙啊?!

      Reddit网友K30:我也修过NCR和Diebold家的ATM。声音绝对不是假的。整个系统都是一堆齿轮滑轮和传送带。

      所以综合来看,按照国外网友的意见,”声音是真的“似乎占绝对优势?
      回复

      使用道具 举报

      12下一页
      推荐阅读更多精彩内容>